The black and white jacket is done (finally).
The pattern is a reprint of a vintage style swing jacket with cut-on kimono sleeves.
The pattern seems to be well drafted and went together well. The only tricky part is the way the neckline is designed, where the collar is cut in one with the front, involving a right angle pivot. I found one of the illustrations confusing here, although the directions were perfectly clear. For me it was just easier to look at the garment and the pattern and it made sense.
The jacket turned out nicely, I like it, and I will wear it.
Here are a couple of detail photos of the back:
I originally planned to use the same black and white trim I used above the peplum between the facing and the lining of the jacket, but when I started to put it in I felt it was too busy with the checked jacket fabric and the print of the lining. In the end I left that transition unadorned:
Although I love the jacket, and am happy to be done with it, there are a few things I think I might do differently if I were to make it again.
To begin with, I have two basic fit issues:
First: after making the muslin in San Francisco we decided that I needed to lengthen the peplum by 2" but not the bodice of the jacket. Now it looks OK as is; it fits correctly and I tend to be short from shoulder to bust-point, so even though I am tall I don't usually have to lengthen patterns in that area, but the seam might look better a little lower. I think a lower seam would reduce the appearance of length in the lower torso, especially when wearing pants. After making another muslin, I would check the final length as I might lengthen the peplum as well. I am not yet convinced this is the best length on me.
Secondly I added shoulder pads to the jacket even though they were not called for in the pattern. This was another design decision based on the muslin. My shoulders roll forward, one more so than the other. On the muslin I had deep creases running from the shoulder line of the jacket. I originally thought I could recut the bodice, redrawing and reshaping the darts to accommodate my personal fit anomalies. Sandra had the brilliant idea that I could probably use the pattern as is and use shoulder pads to even out the inconsistencies in my own frame. This does work well and the jacket looks good. I used almost twice as much shoulder pad on the right as on the left, and it was a little tricky getting it positioned just right, but it makes a big difference.
BUT I am still not perfectly happy with how the shoulder hangs. The collar does not lie symmetrically (because I am not symmetrical, and one side of the jacket is too big. If I make this again I would cut a smaller size on the right front and have to do some finagling to get the sizes to match and reposition the darts.
The last problem I had with the garment is with the collar. Oh it works well and was easy enough, I just have a design issue, which is of course compounded by the unevenness of the fit on me as discussed above.
In the pattern photograph shown above you see how nicely the jacket is shown with the collar turned up partially. I had a good bit of trouble getting my collar to achieve this effect and lie smoothly. I don't know if anyone else has had this problem, or if it was created merely by the addition of shoulder pads and my own asymmetrically, but I don't think this is the case.
Look at the line drawings:
Notice that in the sketch, the collar lies flat and is spread rather widely. My jacket did that quite well:
But I didn't like the way it looked on me. I liked the way it looked much better when I tried to flip the collar up more, but when I did so , the collar and front facing piece buckled and left rather unsightly wrinkles and bumps, quite visible to anyone standing within about 5 feet. This was not acceptable.
I checked reviews on pattern review and noticed that there are a couple of reviews by more accomplished seamstresses than I, neither of whom mentioned having any problem with the collar. But then, when I looked at their photos, I see that they both showed the garments with the collar down flat, as shown in the line drawing.
Either I messed up the construction, my fabric was not particularly suitable to the jacket, or there is a problem with the way the collar and facing go together if one wants the collar to stand up more.
Luckily the wool was pretty amenable to shaping with steam and although I did not get the collar I wanted, I got a pretty acceptable alternative. I spent a lot of time at my ironing board with the jacket on Matilda, a roll of wool, a pressing roll and my handy silicone Orka oven glove, steaming and shaping the collar. I eliminated most of the wrinkles and got the collar to stand, forming more of a roll than a jaunty angle, but it was enough.
Despite this, and despite the fact that I spent a lot more time on this than I originally planned, I am pretty excited about the jacket. It was supposed to be a quick jacket to wear while I lost weight. It still is; it is not perfect but it is good enough. Someday I will learn that I am really happiest when I spend the time to make separate pattern pieces for left and right side, and spend more time altering and perfecting patterns. But I, like most of us I suspect, sometimes just want to sew and not have to fret with pattern making. The problem with coming back to sewing is that I have to make a whole new set of base patterns and that is a lot of work, work I usually, but not always, enjoy.
Finally, here is a picture of me in the jacket. I am not sure it is the most flattering thing I have ever made, but I love it anyway as does G, and in the end, I suppose we are the only ones whose opinions matter:
One of the good things about going to sewing camp is I learn lots of new ways to "get by" and pull a project out of the fire without going through extensive machinations. And the results are often good. If I hadn't started this under Sandra's watchful eye, I would have struggled much more with the fit, and I am not sure I would have been happier with the final result.
A success!